Although the music by Manos Hadjidakis is immediately recognizable even to those who have never seen Never on Sunday (click here for Melina singing in the movie, with thanks to Iulia for the link and MLight for her help with linking music in general), the movie itself, a small classic, had escaped me till last weekend. It was made before I was born but somehow it doesn't get onto the vintage movie channels-- at least not that I've seen (late flash: it will be on Turner Classic Movies at 12 noon on Wednesday, February 28.).
Photo: Greek Ministry of Culture
But now that my school trip to Greece is exactly a month away, it was time to see something like this, and to reflect on how modern Greece is like ancient Greece, but in different ways than one imagines.
I identify very much with the protagonist of the film, Homer Thrace, played by Jules Dassin, who also wrote and directed. Homer is a wide-eyed American and Hellenophile, an "amateur philosopher" on a mission to Greece to find what went wrong with the world after the end of the Golden Age That Was Greece. Aristotle's name is constantly on Homer's lips, and he wonders why so few people live by logic, which was a Greek invention.
Into Homer's logical world comes the defiantly illogical Illya (Melina Mercouri, who won an Oscar for the role, deservedly so), a prostitute who "makes no price" but only sleeps with men she finds interesting. Her home is in the rubble-strewn port town of Piraeus, a few miles down the hill from Athens, and she is popular among all the men for her joie de vivre, fierce independence, and anger at injustice.
She makes one of the most arresting first entrances in all of film when she strides down a dock in Piraeus among all the working stiffs, strips down to her bra and panties in front of everyone, and dives into the Saronic Gulf, daring the men to come in after her.
The stage is thus set for a clash between Ilya's practice and Homer's theory. He spends most of the film attempting to get her to see that being a prostitute is not a logical life, and through sheer dint of persistence finally persuades her to become his pupil for two weeks, My Fair Lady style, to see what she has been missing.
Who wins? It's not hard to guess. Whereas in My Fair Lady attention is lovingly given to the process of education ("The Rain... in Spain... Falls mainly... on the Plain!"), Dassin gives Homer's lessons only a brief montage; the most conspicuous evidence of the new Ilya is in the possessions-- books, a piano-- he brings into her small apartment.
The education, in fact, is a kind of brief diversion, with the real conflict coming with Ilya's would-be landlord and pimp, Mr. Noface, who charges the prostitutes of Piraeus exorbitant rents for their flops next to the gangplanks of the world's navies. In the most joyful of the scenes, the prostitutes go on strike to lower their rents, and Ilya is able to negotiate half-price for them.
Finally even Homer, in the time-honored tradition of comedy, must be won over to Ilya's way. His ouzo- and-broken-glass fueled dance at the end of the movie brings play back into his life. During that time-- and maybe forever, but probably not-- philosophy is forgotten.
It would be easy to write a student essay on this film arguing that the central conflict is between Apollo and Dionysus, or between the two poles of human behavior, control and excess, or of civilization versus nature (thank you, Friedrich Nietzche).
Homer represents the human desire to have things make sense and follow an orderly pattern, and to minimize disruption.
Ilya, on the other hand, would represent the human propensity to go wild, not to worry about consequences, and to give in to one's lower self.
Similarly, a Hellenophile like Homer might think that the ancient Greeks were an Apolline people of order, while the modern Greeks, having lost their ancient dignity, are crazier and more happy-go-lucky, more Dionysian.
The fact is, however, that Never on Sunday is a perfect example of why the Apollo/Dionysus distinction breaks down for most works of art.
Ilya's passion for justice, shown in her hatred for Noface, betrays an underlying seriousness to her way of life that, ironically, Homer tries to disrupt. And her refusal to sleep with Homer at the end-- though he finally realizes he's wanted to all along-- shows that her life is not a Dionysian free-for-all.
Furthermore, that crazy, happy-go-lucky quality was always there in the ancient
Greeks, who loved comedy as much as tragedy. They have always smiled through tears. In the late 5th century, Aristophanes was writing side-splitting comedies for an Athens at war; Dassin's work comes hard on the heels of World War II and the Greek Civil War.
The defiance, independence, and crypto-Apolline quality of comedy is in its refusal to give in to the chaos of a world that has become orderly-- especially an order that is imposed from the outside by exploiters.
Melina Mercouri was a political activist and would be eventually exiled from Greece after a coup d'etat in 1967. Never on Sunday is not an overtly political film, but you can easily see its heart beating for the ideals of justice and love.
Dionysus, in ancient Greece, was as much about order as Apollo. He just showed it in a different way. But that is for another post.